You love real crabmeat, but is imitation crab a worthy substitute? What is imitation crab?
What Is Imitation Crab?
Updated on Jul. 02, 2020
Crabmeat is delicious but it’s also very seasonal—and expensive! Here’s what you need to know about the next best thing: imitation crab.
What Is Imitation Crab?
Just as the name indicates, imitation crab isn’t crab at all, but instead a puree of fish. It’s usually whitefish with a mild flavor like pollack, whiting or haddock, or a blend. The other ingredients may include crab extract, natural coloring and a binder like egg white.
Imitation crab is formulated to have a similar flavor, texture and appearance to typical cooked fresh crab.
How Is Imitation Crab Made?
To start, the whitefish is minced very finely or pureed into a paste. The Japanese name for imitation crab, surimi, translates to “minced fish” because of this first step in the process.
Next, the meat is seasoned to take on the sweet and briny flavor of natural crab. Once the puree is seasoned, it will be shaped depending on the final goal of the product: crabmeat flakes, chunks or crab sticks, which have the appearance of a crab leg and are often used in California rolls and other types of sushi.
If you’re hoping to eat the imitation crab as a vegan substitute for crabmeat, you’re likely out of luck. Almost all imitation crab is made from a base of fish. Even more surprising is the fact that imitation crab may not be gluten-free! Sometimes flour or other grain-based products are used for texture and binding to give the imitation a more crab-like feel.
Is Imitation Crab Healthy?
According to our dietitian, Peggy Woodward, RDN, a 3-ounce serving of imitation crab contains 85 calories, 6 grams of carbohydrate, 25 milligrams of cholesterol and 841 milligrams of sodium. The same-size serving of cooked crab has 101 calories, 0 grams of carbohydrate, 91 milligrams of cholesterol and 324 milligrams of sodium. Both imitation crab and fresh crab have just 1 gram of fat per serving.
The imitation crab is slightly higher in sodium and carbohydrates, but the difference is small. Since it can have additives like sugar and MSG, imitation crab is not as healthy as the real deal. But using the much more affordable imitation crab in recipes will still give you the benefit of a generally healthy meal, like these Avocado “Crab” Boats. If you’re still not convinced, learn how to cook crab legs at home.
How to Cook with Imitation Crab
Use imitation crab as a tasty addition to pasta, salads, soups and chowders. It’s much less expensive than real crabmeat, so it’s a great way to get that full crab flavor in your meals and appetizers without breaking the bank. It’s easy to cook with and requires no special preparation.
In instances like this Baked Crab Dip or Crab-Topped Fish Fillets, imitation crab can be used in a 1:1 ratio in place of the fresh crab in the recipe.
Use Imitation Crab to Make Seafood Salad
Jambalaya Rice SaladMy cold rice salad has a little hint of spice for a classic jambalaya-style kick. Shrimp, tomatoes, ham and peppers give the dish bright colors and a delightful texture. —Karen Rahn, Hixon, Tennessee
Shrimp Panzanella SaladThese days, I’m only cooking for two. After working in the garden, I can dash indoors and have this shrimp and
bread salad on the table pronto. —Kallee Krong-McCreery, Escondido, California
Shrimp Avocado SaladShrimp avocado salad mixes tender shellfish with fresh vegetables for a cool, protein-filled lunch or easy light dinner.
Spicy Crab SaladMy creamy crab salad gets a boost of heat from Sriracha and a tangy touch from lime. It’s ready fast, leaving me more time with guests. —Patti Lavell, Islamorada, Florida
Refreshing Shrimp SaladAvocado, strawberries and shrimp are wonderful together in this filling yet light salad. Balsamic or raspberry vinaigrette dressings go well with the salad, as do Asian-inspired dressings. —Taste Recipes Test Kitchen, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Mediterranean Shrimp Salad in a JarThis Greek salad to go is packed with so much freshness, it instantly brightens up your day. Just layer it all in a jar and pack it up—then serve and enjoy. —Taste Recipes Test Kitchen, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Shrimp Pasta SaladShrimp pasta salad is creamy, crunchy and packed with tender shrimp. This protein-rich macaroni salad is perfect as a light lunch or a side dish for potlucks and picnics.
Cioppino-Mixed Green SaladLiving in California, the "salad bowl" of the United States, I’m inspired to cook nutritious meals like cioppino. Whenever my friends and I get together, this salad—a spin on the classic seafood stew—is the top request. —Cleo Gonske, Redding, California
Healthy Tuna SaladYou do not need full-fat dressing to make a great tuna fish sandwich. Learn how to make healthy tuna salad with a recipe that cuts down on calories and fat, but keeps the classic flavor (and crunch!).
Shrimp & Nectarine SaladFor a cool salad on a hot summer day, I combine shrimp, corn, tomatoes and nectarines with a drizzle of tarragon dressing. We love it chilled, but it's delectable served right away, too. —Mary Ann Lee, Clifton Park, New York
Artichoke Shrimp Pasta SaladI have enjoyed this recipe for as long as I can remember. My mom made it famous, and she passed it down to me on my wedding day. It's one of those potluck staples that folks can't get enough of. —Mary McCarley, Charlotte, North Carolina
Orzo-Tuna Salad with TomatoesStuffed tomatoes provide endless options when you add meat, cheese, rice, veggies – or in this case, orzo. — Jenni Dise, Phoenix, Arizona
Chilled Shrimp Pasta SaladThis chilled salad, along with a nice cool drink, is all you need on a hot summer day. It also makes a nice side dish for sharing anytime. —Mary Price, Youngstown, Ohio
Tuna Nicoise SaladTuna Nicoise salad is a perfect lunch for a weekend or even to make ahead for the work week. Our recipe is traditional with tuna, tomatoes and beans, but is easily adaptable to suit your tastes.
Shrimp Caesar SaladCaesar salad need not be enjoyed as a mere side dish to steak. With crispy fried shrimp topping the plate, our shrimp Caesar salad shines as the star entree of any meal.
Greek Orzo SaladThis tart, refreshing salad is a big hit in my home. All the tasty toppings—including red onions, tomatoes, olives, feta cheese and a zesty dressing—give it extra interest. —Judy Roberts, Las Vegas, Nevada
Shrimp Salad with Cilantro DressingThis pretty salad has such authentic flavor, you'll think you're sitting at a beachside cantina in Acapulco. —Heidi Hall, North St. Paul, Minnesota
Grilled Shrimp PanzanellaI like to liven up typical tossed salad with tender grilled shrimp, bread cubes and feta cheese. The colorful dish is an attractive addition to party buffets. —Veronica Callaghan, Glastonbury, Connecticut
Mediterranean Tuna SaladIf you think tuna salad means lots of mayonnaise, think again! Our Mediterranean tuna salad recipe mixes protein-packed canned tuna, chickpeas, veggies and vinaigrette into a colorful, healthy, never-boring salad or sandwich topper.
Garlic Shrimp & Orzo SaladI enjoy cold pasta salads and rice salads, so I decided to make one with orzo, a rice-shaped pasta. Feel free to add other favorite veggies—like asparagus and green beans—and serve with rolls or pita bread.—Valonda Seward, Coarsegold, California
Herbed Tuna and White Bean SaladThis is a quick and delicious salad that can be made special for guests—or yourself—by grilling fresh tuna steaks instead of using canned. —Charlene Chambers, Ormond Beach, Florida
Calamari SaladThis is one of the seven fish dishes we serve at Christmas time. It is easy to make and quite delicious! I enjoy it served both warm and cold. Either way, it has become one of our traditional dishes each year. The recipe has been passed down to me through my grandparents, who were excellent cooks. —Paul Rinaldi, Easton, Pennsylvania
Shrimp and Spinach Salad with Hot Bacon DressingWhen I meet former co-workers for lunch at our favorite restaurant, we always order this salad. I wanted to share it with my husband, so I made it my mission to re-create it. Mission accomplished! —Lisa Bynum, Brandon, Mississippi
Caribbean Crabmeat SaladThis tart, sweet salad adds a delightful blend of colors and flavors to any table. —Patrisha Thompson,
Sterling, Colorado
Lime-Marinated Shrimp SaladCeviche is a seafood dish of raw fish marinated in citrus juice, which “cooks” the fish without heat. This version starts with cooked shrimp and adds tomatoes, cucumbers and serrano peppers. —Adan Franco, Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Next, learn how to make shrimp ceviche.
Shrimp Scampi Spinach SaladMy husband and I really enjoy both shrimp scampi and fresh spinach salad, so I put the two together. My oldest son loves it, too, and he's only 3! —Jamie Porter, Garnett, Kansas
Garlic Shrimp & Rice SaladFor this easy-to-make main dish salad, you can prepare the rice mixture and chop the vegetables ahead of time. Cook the shrimp at the last minute, then assemble it all together for a light yet satisfying meal. —Diane Nemitz, Ludington, Michigan
Shrimp & Cucumber RoundsI always make these appetizers for our get-togethers. They're easy to prepare and a snappy addition to any party. —Kelly Alaniz, Eureka, California
