We Tried Sole Meuniere, the Dish That Sparked Julia Child's Career

For one of her first meals in Paris, Julia Child ate sole meuniere, a simple-seeming white fish cooked in butter and lemon. In her memoir, My Life in France, she called it “the most exciting meal of my life.” The soon-to-be famous chef was already in her 40s when she tasted this fish, and it may have launched her glorious career.

When we heard this, we just had to taste the fish that changed the course of home cooking!

How to Make Julia Child’s Sole Meuniere

What You’ll Need

Skinless and boneless sole fillets, or other thin white fish fillet (I bought three for two hungry people)
1/4 cup flour on a plate
3 tablespoons clarified butter
4 tablespoons plain butter
Parsley, minced
One lemon, quartered
Salt and pepper

Note: I followed the recipe in The Way to Cook, which provides detailed step-by-step instructions plus troubleshooting tips. There is an abbreviated, more conversational version in Julia’s Kitchen Wisdom, which you may prefer if you like your recipes relaxed and adaptable.

Initial Thoughts

At a glance, I expected this recipe to resemble all the other lemon-spritzed fish dishes I’ve eaten before. Tasty enough, but definitely with a whiff of low-calorie cooking about them. Then I remembered that, as in many classic French recipes, the trick is to showcase simple, quality ingredients with meticulous cooking technique.

With a gulp, I hoped my technique would live up to Julia’s direction.

Kelsey Mueller for Taste Recipes

The First Steps

I called around town until I found a grocery store that sold sole fillets. I struck out on Dover sole, but found a respectable Pacific sole. At home, I left the fish out on the counter and readied my other ingredients. The fish cooks in a flash—the cooking time is less than four minutes—and I knew once I started, I wouldn’t have any time to pause. I sprinkled flour over a large plate, sliced my lemon, and chopped my parsley. (Confession: I rarely prep all my ingredients in advance, preferring to rush around like a maniac while I cook. Just having everything set out on the counter made me feel like a pro.)

To clarify butter, I dumped a few tablespoons into a glass dish and microwaved until the butter had melted and a thin layer of white froth floated on top. I skimmed off the froth with a spoon—these are the milk solids, which burn easily. Without them, the butter can withstand cooking at high heat. In other words, don’t skip this step! (Here’s the recipe in full detail.)

Heat the Pan and Prep the Fish

I set my heaviest cast-iron pan over medium-high heat—Julia’s recipe specifies that you want the fish to brown, which means you need a high initial heat. While it warmed up, I dredged the fillets in the flour and gave them a quick sprinkle of salt and pepper. (I kept glancing back at the book: Is that it? Yes, that’s really all you need.)

When I flicked water at the pan, the drops sizzled over the iron. Ready to cook! I poured in a few spoonfuls of clarified butter, which immediately began to hiss and sizzle. Quickly, I added the fish, placing each fillet so it wasn’t crowded in the pan. You want the fish to fry, not steam.

Love Julia Child? This Taste Recipes editor cooked her classic recipes for an entire week.

Kelsey Mueller for Taste Recipes

**Cook ’til Just Done**

The first side of the fish cooks for two minutes. The whole time, the butter wildly, cheerfully popped and danced, or, as Julia would say, “sputtered.” The browning butter smelled amazingly nutty and delicious. When the timer rang, I carefully eased a spatula under each fillet and gave it a cautious flip. So far, so good! The fillets had achieved a lovely golden brown crust.

I let the fish cook for another two minutes on the other side. Julia specifies that the fish should be just cooked: If it flakes, it’s overcooked. (Told you the technique was exacting!)

Here’s where I confess a misstep: When I tried to remove the fillets from the pan, they were stuck, and in my well-intentioned-but-probably-rough spatula-poking, two of the fragile fillets broke apart. Even with their beautiful brown crust, they looked a bit sad on the plate. What would Julia do? Cry? Never. I straightened my shoulders and tightened my apron. “Never apologize!” Julia would say. I showered the fish with parsley, hiding the worst of the damage.

Next up, adding another gob of butter to the pan to create a sauce. To help remove the stuck fish bits, I added the juice of half my lemon. By the time the butter melted, the sauce was done. As I poured it over the fish, the parsley sizzled up in the heat, and everything smelled so amazing I no longer cared about the broken fillets. Planning to make dessert? Check out this Julia Child’s chocolate mousse recipe.

The Verdict

As soon as I tasted the sole meuniere, I was sorry I’d ever doubted Julia. Outside, the fish was slightly crisp from browning; inside, it was meltingly tender. The sauce was so rich and decadent, like butter’s highest calling. And the lemon’s acidity balanced all the flavors and kept the rich dish from feeling heavy.

I was so fixated on the fish I forgot to make a side—whoops! Luckily I’d made three fillets for me and my husband. We polished them off. Best of all, the meal only took about half an hour to prepare. With practice, this recipe will become a muscle-memory meal for me: one of those dishes you could make in your sleep, but which never fail to impress. Brava, Julia!

Next time, I’ll try to finish off the meal with one of these incredible French desserts.

1 / 40

Chocolate-Glazed Raspberry Eclairs I first made choux pastry in high school for a French class assignment, and I was fascinated. Since then, chocolate-glazed raspberry eclairs have been my favorite pastry to make. I garnish each eclair either with a single fresh raspberry or with a sprinkling of crushed freeze-dried raspberries. —Elisabeth Larsen, Pleasant Grove, Utah Looking for a fancy breakfast pastry? Learn how to make delicate, swirled French cruller doughnuts at home. Go to Recipe

Palmier Cookies Recipe photo by Taste Recipes

Palmiers Palmiers take just two ingredients to make these impressive but easy-to-do French pastries, which are often called palm leaves. —Taste Recipes Test Kitchen, Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This Is the Surprising Dish That Sparked Julia Child’s Career

Now Trending

How to Make Julia Child’s Sole Meuniere

What You’ll Need

Initial Thoughts

Kelsey Mueller for Taste Recipes

The First Steps

Heat the Pan and Prep the Fish

Kelsey Mueller for Taste Recipes

Cook ’til Just Done

The Verdict

**Cook ’til Just Done**