Many recipes call for you to add a single bay leaf to soups or sauces, only to take it back out later. Why is this a common practice, and does it actually do anything? Let's uncover the mysteries behind that leaf.
This Is Why We Always Put a Bay Leaf in Our Soup
Have you ever tried to chew a bay leaf? They aren’t exactly pleasant. When fresh, these thick leaves tend to taste more like eucalyptus than anything else, and it’s easy to see why chefs tend to remove them before serving soups or stews. But why do people use them in long-simmering dishes at all? As with many herbs, it’s all down to how the flavors combine.
Letting Things Stew
The key is letting the bay leaves sit and simmer in your dish. Over time, the heat breaks down some of the more potent leaf flavors, especially that menthol-like tinge, and turns them into a gentler, more pleasant element of your soup.
Combine this transformed flavor with the rest of your recipe—particularly in liquid or high-moisture foods—and the bay leaf adds a slightly sweet, sort of tea-like note. It’s a fairly mild addition that sits in the background and enhances other, bolder flavors. It’s often only when people are given a blind taste test that they notice one dish has a better flavor profile than another, with the addition of nothing but the humble bay leaf. This works particularly well in recipes that include meats such as chicken or beef.
But, after an hour or so or simmering, the bay leaf itself doesn’t do much good, and doesn’t have the right texture to eat, so it is discarded. No one wants to chew on that rough leaf in the middle of an excellent soup.
Keeping Bay Leaves on Hand
A couple important notes about using these leaves: Firstly, there are two different types, Turkish (rounder) and California (more blade-shaped). California bay leaves are known to have a stronger, sharper flavor, while the Turkish version is milder and sweeter.
Secondly, while bay leaves can last for months in storage quite easily (the freezer is usually suggested), they will be a lot stronger when they are fresh, so make sure you adjust your recipes accordingly. In fact, some chefs prefer working with the dried version so that the flavor isn’t too strong. Speaking of recipes, cooks have been coming up with interesting new uses for bay leaves, such as using them in desserts for a more unusual mint-like bite. Would you dare?
Put Those Bay Leaves to Good Use
Instant Pot Potato SoupThis is a crowd-pleasing Instant Pot potato soup that is cheesy, creamy and studded with bacon bits and it's ready in just about 30 minutes.
Tomato SoupIf you're looking for the best tomato soup recipe, you've found it! Bursting with bright tomato flavor, this easy-to-make soup is the perfect partner for a gooey grilled cheese.
Classic French Onion SoupThis rich and comforting French onion soup recipe is surprisingly simple to make at home. And it rivals the soup you’ll find at any restaurant.
Broccoli Cheddar SoupWhen it comes to easy and cheesy comfort food, nothing's better than broccoli cheddar soup.
Hearty Homemade Chicken Noodle SoupI'm not sure any other old fashioned soup recipes can compare with this! This satisfying soup with a hint of cayenne is brimming with vegetables, chicken and noodles. The recipe is from my father-in-law, but I tweaked it to make it my own. —Norma Reynolds, Overland Park, Kansas
Easy Butternut Squash SoupWhen the weather turns cold, get cozy with a bowl of this butternut squash soup. This recipe is super easy. The cream adds richness, but if you're looking to cut calories, it can be omitted. —Taste Recipes Test Kitchen, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Priscilla’s Vegetable ChowderThis is the perfect soup to warm up with on a cold fall or winter day. Serve it in a bread bowl to make it extra special. —Rhodes Bake-N-Serv, Jenna Jackson, Salt Lake City, Utah
Pressure-Cooker English Pub Split Pea SoupThis family favorite is the same recipe my grandmother used. Now with the magic of today's appliances, I can spend 15 minutes putting it together, walk away for a bit and then it's "soup's on!" Finish it with more milk if you like your split pea soup a bit thinner. —Judy Batson, Tampa, Florida
Vegetable Lentil SoupVegetarians and veggie-curious eaters will both love this vegetable lentil soup that's equal parts healthy and tasty.
Easy Pot Sticker SoupSince my husband and I have soup often, I’m always coming up with something new. I saw potstickers in the freezer and decided to feature them in Asian soup. The results were delicious. Rice vinegar provides just the right tang, and the green onions and carrots add color. Stir in chopped cabbage or bok choy if you like. A little sesame oil goes a long way, but you can always add a bit more. —Darlene Brenden, Salem, Oregon
Clam ChowderEnjoy a big bowl of award-winning clam chowder, a traditional favorite from the New England coast. It's creamy and chock-full of clams, potatoes, bacon and more.
Borscht SoupSavor the vibrant flavors of this classic borscht soup, featuring tender beets, vegetables and a tangy beef broth that's sure to warm you up on chilly days.
Spinach and Tortellini SoupA simple tomato-enhanced broth is perfect for cheese tortellini and fresh spinach. Increase the garlic and add Italian seasoning to suit your taste. —Debbie Wilson, Burlington, North Carolina
Chicken and DumplingsThis homestyle chicken and dumpling soup recipe is just like mom's with its classic mirepoix base and doughy drop dumplings.
Thai Chicken Noodle SoupThis slow cooker soup is a semi-homemade version that coaxes all of the flavor out of a rotisserie chicken. Do the prep work the day before and toss the broth-making ingredients into the slow cooker in the morning. It's a snap to finish when you get home. —Beth Jacobson, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Spinach and Sausage Lentil SoupDuring the cooler months of the year, this soup makes regular appearances on our dinner table. This is one of those winter soup recipes that's approved by all, including my picky 6-year-old. —Kalyn Gensic, Ardmore, Oklahoma
Dill Chicken SoupI could eat soup for every meal of the day, all year long. I particularly like dill and spinach—they add a brightness to this light and healthy soup. —Robin Haas, Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts
Creamy Cauliflower Pakora SoupMy husband and I often crave pakoras, deep-fried fritters from India. I wanted to get the same flavors but use a healthier cooking technique, so I made soup using all the classic spices and our favorite veggie, cauliflower! —Melody Johnson, DePere, Wisconsin
Spicy Montana ChiliThis thick and chunky chili has some kick to it. I like to top it with shredded cheddar and then serve it with a side of cornbread. —Donna Evaro, Casper, Wyoming
Creamy Chicken Gnocchi SoupI tasted a similar soup at Olive Garden and wanted to try and make it myself. Here's the delicious result! It's wonderful on a cool evening. —Jaclynn Robinson, Shingletown, California
Contest-Winning Pizza SoupThis contest-winning pizza soup is a hearty and fun take on the all-time comfort food that is pizza. Try all your favorite pizza toppings, albeit as soup ingredients instead.
Beef Lentil SoupThis beef lentil soup combines tender ground beef, nutritious lentils, and fresh vegetables in a hearty broth, making it a comforting one-pot meal all year long.
Broccoli Beer Cheese SoupWhether you include the beer or not, this soup tastes wonderful. I always make extra and pop single servings into the freezer. —Lori Lee, Brooksville, Florida
Sausage Potato SoupI rely on this thick, chunky Sausage Potato Soup on busy weeknights when I'm too tired to spend a lot of time preparing dinner. The whole family enjoys the wonderful flavor of the smoked sausage. —Jennifer LeFevre, Hesston, Kansas. Make sure you try this old-fashioned potato soup recipe.
Stone Soup RecipeAfter reading the Stone Soup story, our Test Kitchen enjoyed concocting this version of the folktale classic. It’s chock-full of veggies and lots more ingredients…enough for everyone to bring something to add to the fun and flavor!
Slow-Cooker Corn ChowderI combine and refrigerate the ingredients for this slow-cooker corn chowder the night before. In the morning, I pour the mixture into my crock and turn it on. When I come home from work, a hot, tasty meal awaits. —Mary Hogue, Rochester, Pennsylvania
Best Lasagna SoupAll the traditional flavors of lasagna come together in this heartwarming bowl of comfort. —Sheryl Olenick, Demarest, New Jersey
Want to try a popular variation of this cozy dish? Try this viral lasagna soup recipe.
Mexican Chicken Corn ChowderI like to make this smooth, creamy soup when company comes to visit. Its zippy flavor is full of southwestern flair. My family enjoys dipping slices of homemade bread in this chowder to soak up every bite! —Susan Garoutte, Georgetown, Texas
Pho (Vietnamese Noodle Soup)Pho is one of Vietnam's most well-known dishes. For many families, the cooking of the dish is a true labor of love and care. With its aromatic broth, slurpable rice noodles and many delicious garnish options, it is very easy to customize a bowl to suit your tastes. —Taste Recipes Test Kitchen
Lobster BisqueMy grandmother would make lobster bisque all the time, so I've always thought of it as comfort food. If you don't care to cook live lobsters, they can usually be cooked where you buy them. Just be sure to say that you want to keep the shells; they are the key to the most delicious soup! —James Schend, Taste Recipes Deputy Editor
Cheesy Wild Rice SoupWe often eat easy-to-make winter soup recipes when there’s not a lot of time to cook. I replaced the wild rice in the original recipe with a boxed rice mix. This creamy concoction is now a favorite.
Traditional Italian Wedding SoupYou don’t have to be Italian to love this easy-to-make soup with tiny round pasta! Add homemade meatballs but use ready-made stock and rotisserie chicken.—Mary Sheetz, Carmel, Indiana
Simple Salmon ChowderI've lived on a farm in the Yakima Valley all my life. I have a big garden, and by the end of fall, my cellar shelves are full of canned fruits and vegetables. This salmon chowder recipe uses some of the root vegetables I grow—along with the delicious salmon that is so plentiful here. —Josephine Parton, Granger, Washington
Mexican-Inspired Chicken SoupThis zesty chicken taco soup is loaded with corn and black beans in a mildly spicy red broth. As a busy mom of three young children, I'm always looking for dinner recipes that can be prepared in the morning. The kids love the taste of this easy soup. —Marlene Kane, Lainesburg, Michigan
Wild Rice and Mushroom SoupRich and comforting, wild rice and mushroom soup is a great go-to for a hearty weekday lunch or dinner. If you're a vegetarian—or you're cooking for one—just swap in vegetable stock for the beef broth.
Vegetarian White Bean SoupThe home economists in our Test Kitchen simmered up this fresh-tasting meatless soup. Hearty with two kinds of beans, it makes a satisfying entree. Round out the meal with Walnut Zucchini Muffins or warm dinner rolls.
Greek Tomato Soup with OrzoMy recipe for manestra, which means orzo in Greek, is effortless and very easy to make. You need only a few steps to transform simple ingredients into a creamy one-pot wonder. —Kiki Vagianos, Melrose, Massachusetts
Southwest-Style Wedding SoupI turned leftover ground chicken into meatballs and dreamed up this cozy southwestern soup. Now my Italian family asks for it over traditional wedding soup. —Teena Petrus, Johnstown, Pennsylvania
Ground Turkey Vegetable SoupLow-sodium ingredients don't diminish the full flavor of this brothy ground turkey vegetable soup. The turkey lends a heartiness that everyone will welcome on a cold blustery evening. —Bonnie LeBarron, Forestville, New York
Cream of Celery Soup RecipeThis rich cream of celery soup recipe will warm up any family gathering or quiet evening at home. With just the right amount of onion flavor, it's creamy and crowd-pleasing. —Janet James, Bluff City, Tennessee
Easy Pork PosoleLooking for a meal in a bowl? Sit down to a Mexican classic full of cubed pork, sliced sausage, hominy and more. It all goes into the slow cooker, so you can come home at night to a table-ready dinner. —Greg Fontenot, The Woodlands, Texas
Curried Chicken SoupMy German mother would occasionally cook dishes that were not traditional German recipes. One of my favorites was her Curry Chicken Soup. I've added my own touches to it, such as the chickpeas, coconut milk and fresh cilantro.—Deanna Hindenach, Paw Paw, Michigan
Taco SoupLove chili? Give our easy taco soup recipe a try. Filled with ground beef, chiles, beans and stewed tomatoes, this one-pot meal is a snap to put together. Everyone in the family will have fun adding their favorite toppings!
Cauliflower Cheddar SoupWhen I created this cauliflower cheddar soup at the last minute for an impromptu ice skating get-together, it was a hit. —Rosa Renee McEldowney, Jackson, Michigan
Buffalo Chicken ChiliThis Buffalo chicken chili is rich in the best way. The cream cheese, blue cheese and tangy hot sauce join forces for a dinner recipe everyone will love. —Peggy Woodward, Shullsburg, Wisconsin
French Onion Soup with MeatballsI got the idea for how to make this soup after I went to a brewhouse restaurant that put ale in their gravy. I make this every time the weather starts to cool down in the fall—it's comfort food for the soul. —Crystal Holsinger, Surprise, Arizona
