Annamarie Higley FOR TASTE OF HOME
ANNAMARIE HIGHLEY FOR TASTE OF HOME
Pros:
-
Comes in eight standard sizes
-
More than 50 styles and patterns available for the 2x3 size
-
Securely packaged and lies flat upon unwrapping
-
Sticky rubber backing prevents slips; no rug pad needed
-
Liquids don't seep through past rubber backing
-
Washes up easily in the machine without any changes in material or color
Cons:
-
Colors look slightly different from the product listing
-
Not able to go into the dryer
-
Pricier than the other options on this list
Comfort and easy care instructions are nice. But one of the top traits folks look for in the best kitchen rugs is visual appeal—and Annie Selke’s Washable Rugs are some of the most stylish on the market. Choosing a style may take some time, but that’s not a bad thing—the 2×3 rug comes in more than 50 different patterns and colors. If the 2×3 doesn’t suit your space, choose from the eight standard sizes available.
Our test subject arrived securely packaged and easily laid completely flat once unrolled. We were immediately impressed with how nice the rug looked and felt—it is definitely top-tier in terms of product quality. We chose a grey color that differs ever so slightly from the photo online, leaning a bit warmer than we expected. However, there are swatches available for purchase if you’re concerned about a little variation.
ANNAMARIE HIGHLEY FOR TASTE OF HOME
It’s a thin, tightly-woven rug with a smooth surface and a sticky backing that prevents liquids from soaking through. The backing is stable on hardwood and not a slip risk, but it does move slightly before catching itself if you pivot around on it. We love that there’s no rug pad required for this one. Even better, we found it fairly resistant to stains after blotting and tossing it in the washing machine. That’s right—this one is also machine-washable!
While our cordless vacuum had trouble removing crumbs without sucking up the material, if you go with the nap, it’s a bit easier. Sure, the price is a bit steep compared to other options. That said, we found that it’s a good value when compared to the quality. We predict this pick will last longer after regular use than most of the others we tested.
ANNAMARIE HIGHLEY FOR TASTE OF HOME
ANNAMARIE HIGHLEY FOR TASTE OF HOME
Pros:
-
Very inexpensive
-
Anti-slip glue backing prevents liquids from soaking all the way through to the floor
-
Available in multiple sizes, including square and round options
-
Nonslip backing hugs hard floors well
-
11 colors and patterns to choose from
-
Machine-washable
-
Resistant to stains
-
No rug pad needed
Cons:
-
Took more than four days for shipping creases to settle
-
Liquids difficult to soak up once absorbed
-
Corners are a bit frayed where the material was cut and tied off
-
Difficult to vacuum; rug is easily sucked up
Sometimes, there’s just not a lot of room in the budget. But that’s just fine—there are still options out there that offer good quality at a lower price point, like the Lahome Boho Tribal Area Rug. Ringing up at less than a quarter of the price as our best overall winner, this humble kitchen rug comes in multiple sizes and shapes, along with 11 pattern and color choices. Like the other non-natural fiber options on our list, this one is also machine-washable—no spot treatments required—making it easy to maintain.
Walking over the rug doesn’t make it slip or slide, thanks to the small, rubber-like dots on the back that offer traction. We don’t feel that this one is a slipping hazard or requires a rug pad, though we’d be wary to tango on it. It also repelled liquids fairly well at first, with none of the water we spilled seeping through to the back. Liquids do slowly absorb after sitting on the mat for a few seconds, but a quick spin in the washer pulled out any stains that settled into the material.
One place where this rug struggled was in its finishing touches. The way it was packaged left several fold creases that took more than four days to settle. The corners—where the material was cut and tied off—were a bit frayed, and it was difficult to vacuum due to the lightweight nature of the material. Despite that, it’s durable, and we don’t foresee any issues with unraveling, even given the slight fringe on the edging. We’d happily put up with these slight imperfections for a budget pick.
Other Rugs We Tested
Our product testing team tested nearly a dozen popular kitchen rugs to find the best. In addition to the four best kitchen rugs above, there were other rugs our team liked. Below are a few kitchen rugs that were close to making our list of favorites.
- Fulton Standing Mat: Our testers like this kitchen mat’s soft, smooth, vegan cactus leather. The edges are beveled, and the base of the mat is made from a cork and foam composite, so it’s cushier than straight cork. “I liked this immediately when I stepped on it,” says tester Catherine Ward. “My feet are usually really sore at the end of the day, and my back aches if standing in one place for too long. I didn’t feel the fatigue and throbbing in my feet that I usually have at the end of the day.” Ultimately, our team found the Fulton rug slightly less stylish than the others listed above, but it’s a sturdy mat that proves easy to clean.
- Caulkins Anti-Fatigue Mat: This rug is a good value for an anti-fatigue kitchen mat, especially compared to other budget picks our team tested. The biggest issue our testing team found with this mat is that the non-slip backing doesn’t grip the floor as well as it could, which could potentially create a slipping hazard.
- Abdulraheem Comfort Standing Anti-Fatigue Mat: While a little pricier than some of the other rugs we tested, our team liked how easy this kitchen rug is to clean. Plus, it’s durable and has a nice sloped edge, which makes it harder to kick and bump into. Tester Maggie Knoebel found that it held its own against heavy-duty, commercial kitchen rugs. She just wished it were a little longer and stickier on the bottom for better grip.
What To Look For When Buying Kitchen Rugs
When it comes to finding a good kitchen rug, there are a lot of subjective aspects to consider. It’s best to opt for a brand that offers many patterns, colors and sizes, especially for those who prefer a more put-together cooking space.
While kitchen rugs won’t offer the same comfort as an anti-fatigue mat, they do offer myriad benefits over having no floor covering at all, and some materials do take some stress off of joints. Popular kitchen mat materials include cotton, jute, polyester and wool. While some prefer natural materials, many folks consider synthetics easier to care for and less expensive.
Size is also a consideration. “Some kitchen rugs can extend the entire length along a wall of cabinetry which can be a strong visual design element as well as lots of comfort for walking back and forth. Shorter sizes may work well in front of the sink and dishwasher section,” notes Susan.
However, there are also a few concerns to keep in mind for any rug you pick, no matter the material or color. Overall, it’s imperative that every option is resistant to water and stains, holds up to its own recommended care instructions and offers a slip-resistant lining that prevents accidental falls.
Why You Should Trust Us
ANNAMARIE HIGHLEY FOR TASTE OF HOME
Our Product Testing Team is comprised of enthusiastic, experienced shoppers. Some of us have backgrounds in professional kitchens, but most of us are humble home cooks passionate about finding kitchen items that offer the best bang for our buck.
Our testing team has three years of experience researching and evaluating everything from the best coffee subscriptions to the best flower delivery services. We take our testing seriously and would never recommend a product we don’t love—regardless of popularity or the brand name.
For this article, we also spoke with Susan Serra, CKD, CAPS and President at Susan Serra Associates, Inc., where she provides kitchen and dining design services. She’s also the founder of Scandinavian Made, a store for both new and vintage handwoven Swedish rugs. Susan is an award-winning kitchen design professional who has been designing kitchens since 1986.
How We Found the Best Kitchen Rugs
In order to find the best kitchen rugs, we tested eight different kitchen rugs from eight different brands, focusing on bestsellers with strong reviews. We tested every rug in the running for the following features:
- Packaging and shipping
- Absorbency
- Size
- Material
- Care
- Value
While some of these data points are easily found on the product listings, we wanted to get a full picture of each pick’s performance prior to making any recommendations. We brought each of the eight rugs into our Product Testing Lab to run a full profile in order to truly find the best options. For those that claimed to have anti-fatigue properties, we partnered with the Taste Recipes Test Kitchen to do an additional test that analyzed the team’s comfort after several days of standing.
Tests include a number of hands-on experiments with the following tests holding the most weight: Checking for creases upon arrival (and how easily they flatten); how well each rug absorbs 1/4 cup of water splashed onto it and whether the moisture bleeds through the bottom; a pass/fail test checking for slippage; how well each pick holds up to its own recommended care instructions after we rub in some yogurt, oil and dirt.
In the end, four of our prospects didn’t make the cut. The four that did earn high marks across the board impressed our team enough to make this official list of the best kitchen rugs available.
FAQ
Is a rug in the kitchen a good idea?
Using a kitchen rug is a solid solution to spills and slips in the kitchen, but there are a few things to consider. Not every rug offers the traits required for a good kitchen rug. “Rugs that are too thick and soft will be more difficult (and slower) to walk on than a thinner rug that has a pad underneath it,” says Susan. “Rug materials that are easy to clean are the best option to use in the kitchen.”
Should you put a rug in front of the kitchen sink?
Putting a rug in front of the kitchen sink adds a barrier between potential spills and kitchen tiles, which prevents water from affecting the kitchen floor. For those who have to hand-wash dishes, it can also add an additional layer of comfort while standing for long periods. However, not all kitchen rugs offer that benefit. “It’s a good idea to test out more than one pad density to find the type that works best for your comfort needs,” says Susan.
What type of rugs are best for a kitchen?
“Rugs come in an endless variety of fabrics,” explains Susan. She says that mats might be considered the easiest to clean as they can be cleaned right after spills occur. But for those who want an authentic material and style to complement the kitchen design, rugs are a better choice. “Vintage rugs can be a great solution for the kitchen as they are already broken in and have a stylish patina as a one-of-a-kind decorative piece.”
Those looking for the charm of a vintage rug with the added benefit of cushioning may be able to replicate the look with a woven rug from somewhere like Ruggable, which offers hundreds of different styles and patterns.