Pros:
-
Built-in filter
-
Easy to clean
-
Large capacity
-
Durable construction
Cons:
-
Finer grinds release grounds in the mug
Want to pair your coveted Stanley Aerolight coffee tumbler with the best pour-over coffee maker? Look no further—the Stanley Classic Perfect-Brew is just as rugged and ready for the outdoors as the brand’s other drinkware. With a stylish matte finish and cylinder-shaped removable mesh filter, this utilitarian option is ready for a trip to the woods or trail.
"This Stanley pour-over has a unique filter system compared to the others we tested. It cleans up easily and brews a decent amount of coffee, enough to fill a 20-oz. tumbler in one brew."
Sheri Kaz
Product Tester
A reusable cylinder-shaped metal filter screws into place, so there’s never a need to run out and grab additional paper filters. The unit is stable yet lightweight, given that it’s made of stainless steel. It has water-measuring lines inside, which help when filling a thermos. And fill a thermos it does, especially considering the generous 20-ounce capacity. Despite the size, it’s also very simple to clean. The filter unscrews, and from there, it’s just a matter of rinsing out the grounds and wiping down the interior.
It has a rather slow seeping time that produces a robust cup of coffee with a slightly bitter flavor. While we didn’t love that some minuscule grounds snuck into the mug, that’s to be expected from a pour-over with a built-in filter. Although this has a metal tab as a handle, it wasn’t hot to the touch, so there’s no need for an oven mitt while pouring. Solid construction that lasts a lifetime is Stanley’s bread and butter, and they certainly didn’t skimp on this stylish staple.
Pros:
-
Dual mesh permanant filter
-
Eco-friendly
-
Easy to clean
-
Large capacity
-
Smooth coffee
-
Affordable
Cons:
-
Not dishwasher safe
-
Fragile
A carafe-style pour-over coffee maker is a great way to enjoy a coffee subscription for total caffeine fiends. The Coffee Gator pour-over is an affordable and stylish alternative to a pricier Chemex but with all the bells and whistles you’d want in a brewer. Namely, the larger 27-ounce carafe offers plenty of brew for entertaining or enjoying a few cups throughout the day.
"I like this carafe style much better than the ones with the fancy wood/cork/leather. The handle makes it easy to manuever and clean. The pour spout is a little wide but not splashy. Five stars in my book!"
Sheri Kaz
product tester
Like its luxe cousins, the Coffee Gator carafe is made from fragile glass, meaning that it’s not exactly dishwasher compatible. However, a bottle brush is your best friend. It can easily sneak in and mop up any unsightly spots. Plus, unlike the picks on this list with finicky collars, we appreciate that this one has a handle for burn mitigation.
The Gator has a reusable dual-layer permanent filter that keeps grounds out, making it a good choice for the environment (and your stomach). Discrete white measurements printed on the glass helps ensure that each brew comes out perfectly. Just be sure to use the right grounds for your palate!
“At first, I used finer grounds with a longer pull time, resulting in a more bitter brew than when I used a coarser grind and a shorter pull time,” notes Sheri. “Interestingly, the coarser grind tasted smoother and was a decent cup of coffee. Funny how the grind and pull time affect the taste so much. Each user will likely need to experiment to find what tastes best to them.”
What to Look for When Buying a Pour-Over Coffee Maker
When looking for a pour-over coffee maker, there are a few factors to consider. First, serving size. While some pour-over coffee makers come with a carafe that’s capable of brewing an entire pot, others are a single-serve size that fits directly over a mug. Folks who want to brew coffee while entertaining should keep potential crowds in mind when committing to a pour-over.
Next is material. Operating without a good oven mitt means opting for a pour-over that comes with its own thermal sleeve or is made from thermal-resistant materials. Additionally, while some materials like glass and ceramic look a bit nicer on the counter, picking an easily breakable brewer may not be the best move for folks who are a bit clumsy before they enjoy their morning cup.
You’ll also want to consider whether it’s worth investing in a pour-over with a permanent filter. The alternative is using disposable paper filters, which are much easier to clean but also add additional waste. They also require regular replacements, upping the maintenance cost of the pour-over.
Lastly, think about cleanup. While plastic pour-overs may offer a cheaper price and lightweight feel, they may require hand-washing over an easy cycle in the dishwasher. Additionally, larger carafes require a bit more care than their smaller counterparts when scrubbing each piece, which is worth keeping in mind.
How We Found the Best Pour-Over Coffee Makers
For this test, we used Colectivo Blue Heeler whole medium-roast coffee beans, the Breville Smart Grinder Pro and a Fellow gooseneck kettle with water heated to 205 degrees Fahrenheit (unless otherwise noted). We also followed the manufacturer’s instructions regarding the coffee-to-water ratio for brewing. If there were no instructions, we used 12 grams of coffee grounds and eight ounces of water. Our testers then taste-tested the coffee black, then, if desired, with a splash of half-and-half. Overall, our expert Product Testing Team:
- Tested 13 coffee makers and performed roughly four tests on each
- Collected roughly 350 data points
- Spent an estimated 32 hours on this test, including researching, sourcing, intaking and testing
The Tests
- Taste: Testers make a batch of coffee, following the yield, ground coarseness and brewing process recommended by the manufacturer. They then taste the coffee, flagging any acidity/bitterness, sweetness or floral notes. Testers also label each batch on a scale from very weak to very strong.
- Flow rate: Testers time the flow rate, noting how long it takes each batch to brew. If the coffee maker brews into a carafe, testers divide the total time. This determines how long it takes to make a single cup of coffee.
- Heat retention: Testers set the Fellow gooseneck kettle to the optimal brewing temperature of 205 degrees (or, if the manufacturer makes a different recommendation, testers will use that number). They then note how well heat retains post-brew by measuring the temperature of the coffee with a liquid thermometer.
- Cleaning: Testers clean the coffee maker and either dispose of or clean the filter, depending on the type. They then note the ease of the process.
Other Pour-Overs We Tested
- COSORI Pour-Over Coffee Maker: Overall, we enjoyed this brew experience. The permanent filter is outstanding, allowing no grounds into the carafe. However, disassembling the wood handle for cleaning makes it a bit more complicated than other options.
- Hario V60: Sheri noted that she isn’t especially impressed with the coffee’s taste.
- Kalita Wave 185 Stainless Steel Coffee Dripper: While attractive, this one produces a bitter coffee and leaves grounds in the cup.
- Kalita Wave 185 Glass Dripper: The plastic brim feels cheap. Compared to the competition, this one seems a little overpriced.
- Bodum Coffee Maker with Permanent Filter: Taking off the cork and leather is easy but tedious, and this one leaves a little silt behind.
- OXO Pour-Over Coffee Maker with Water Tank: This is perfect for the multitasker who doesn’t want to take the time to slowly pour water over the grounds. Just fill the attached water tank and let it do its thing. That said, with an all-plastic construction, we don’t expect it to last.
Why You Should Trust Us
I’ve tested dozens of foods and drinks for Taste Recipes, informing pieces like the best coffee concentrates and the best coffee of the month clubs. Not only am I Taste Recipes’s resident food and drinks expert, but I’m also a total java junkie. Sure, I like looking at roasts, regional sources and aromas. But at the heart of things, I just really love a good cup of coffee.
Our Product Testing and Shopping Teams have a combined decade of experience testing and evaluating products. As purveyors of everything from mushroom coffee to the best espresso grinders, we are passionate about our morning brew. We conducted all tests in our Product Testing Lab under controlled conditions. Our team spent an estimated 32 hours on this test, including researching, sourcing, intaking and testing the products.
I also spoke to Cortney Kern, coffee roaster, latte artist and owner of Whimsical Woods Coffee, for his insight into what makes a good pour-over coffee maker.
FAQ
How do you make a pour-over coffee?
While pour-overs intimidate some coffee newbies, they’re actually rather simple. Start by setting your pour-over on top of its carafe (or, for single cups, over your mug). Then, add a filter if necessary. Some come with their own built-in permanent filters. From there, just measure out your desired amount of coffee, put it into the filter and heat up your electric kettle. We recommend using water around 205 degrees Fahrenheit, but some pour-over brands may have their own temperature suggestions to follow. For a nice, medium-strong cup, use about 12 grams of ground beans for every eight ounces of water.
According to Cortney, the secret to a good pour-over is starting with a strong, saturating bloom. Use a gooseneck kettle for a precise pour for the best results. He also recommends working quickly to avoid any added bitterness.
“When I do a pour-over, my bloom is slow in a circular motion, starting in the middle and going outwards,” says Cortney. “Once my initial bloom phase time is up, I pour water aggressively out of the range server. This makes for a stormy slurry of the grounds getting saturated at a high rate of speed. This results in a smoother cup in the end, which is my preference cause I don’t want bitterness or over-extraction.”